Without a doubt, the reasons for the failure of the entire security apparatus and its doctrine must be thoroughly investigated and appropriate conclusions drawn.
Of course, there will be guilty parties. Some may even be charged with high treason. Anything is possible.
Donate For Independent and Free Pro-Israel News of “VonNaftali”
Make an independent pro Israel Blog (Non-Profit) possible. Donate 1.8 US-Dollar or more. COMPANIES WHICH ‘VONNAFTALI’ REPORTED ABOUT ARE ESPECIALLY INVITED TO MAKE A DONATION. Google Translate now integrated. You can access all articles in all the languages Google Translate offers for translation. Become MEMBER OF ‘VONNAFTALI BUSINESS CLUB’ to get more and exclusive news on Business&more> https://buymeacoffee.com/vonnaftali הוֹדִיעוּ בָעַמִּים, עֲלִילֹתָיו
$1.80
The elites are aware of these possibilities. So they want to create a slippery slope, especially on the part of the deep state, so that the balls reliably roll into the right basket. In the end, Netanyahu must be to blame. He and only he.
This saves the elites’ power system, and they can continue to enrich themselves undisturbed in this rather socialist-led state and live out their privileges and unhinged claims to power.
A state commission is certainly the best method, but not within the framework of this rather authoritarian, left-wing central state aka ‘deep state’.
A problem that all democracies currently have. Trump and Milei currently seem to be the only ones who can pull the teeth out of this deep state. Let’s hope they succeed. Bureaucracy is not Democracy. Fact.
Israel also needs its Trump and its DOGE. Not yet seen. But one can already set the conditions for a state commission to investigate the failure of the security system and the elites, which contributed to the 7/10 genocidal massacre.
In all of this, one must never lose sight of the fact that the main cause is the genocidal, antidemocratic ideology of “Palestinianism“. It was the “Palestinians” and their organizations like Hamas & Co who committed this crime against humanity on 7/10.
This means that one can now discuss some ideas on how such a commission can be optimally established.
0. A complete democratic reform is needed that leads to the complete disempowerment of the deep state. A State Commission makes only sense after a democratic reform of the state structures. Means de-powerment of the deep state. We currently have a highly biased and unbalanced state structure that is disadvantageous to the elected ones. No High Court that stands above the people as the sovereign, no IDF that is only committed to its ethics and some left leaning abstract ideas of democracy pitched against the Jewish people and Judaism, no AG that is the legal counselor, the state attorney and the representative of the people against the government in one person. By the way, this is absurd because the government is elected by the people. The government and the Knesset are the only legitimate representatives of the people because the people elect them. There are some more structural fails to be repaired, like restoring free speech or writing a real Constitution. For the moment, the State Comptroler seems to me to be the ideal head of this state commission.
1. Any lobby organisation pretending to have a mandate to speak for the “families” must show/prove its mandate, open its finances and decision structures, and have open and transparent communications.
2. This failure on 7/10 does not only concern the State of Israel and all Israelis. It also concerns the Diaspora. Why? The Jewish State of Israel promises/promised to be a safe harbour for all Jews. This mission failed: pathetic, epic and terrifying. Hence, the Diaspora must have a mandate in this commission. There are a lot of brilliant minds in the Diaspora who stand unequivocally on the side of Israel.
3. The self-empowered “family spokespersons” should act with respect. Storming the Knesset as alleged representatives of the people or anyone else (without representative status) is unacceptable. No NGO can substitute by self-declaration for the people, the sovereign, who expressed their will in free, secret elections. NGOs, among others, must also uphold democratic standards. It is legitimate that NGOs express their particular interests, but they are not above the citizens or electoral, let alone substitute for the electoral. The legitimacy of NGOs is always less than that of an elected parliament. Fact. No NGO stands above the people, no matter how large their rallies are. The largest and only relevant rally is called ‘elections’. That’s the end of the story.
4. The High Court, the AG and some NGOs (financed by foreign funds) and media must be investigated, too. Not only the IDF, Shin Bet and governments since 2005.
Pic AI-generated. Illustrative. First published 5.03.2025