Israel will be more similar to New Zealand than to Turkey after the Justice Reform

New Zealand is considered one of the best democracy in the world. And Israel will bear many more similarities with New Zealand than with Turkey, according to rabid left-wing critics.

One Chamber

The political system of New Zealand has one chamber, which is the unicameral Parliament known as the House of Representatives. It is made up of 120 members of Parliament (MPs) who are elected through a mixed-member proportional (MMP) system. The House of Representatives is responsible for making laws, approving the government’s budget, and holding the government accountable for its actions. The government is formed by the political party or coalition that can command the support of the majority of the House of Representatives.

120 Members of Parliament

The Parliament of New Zealand has a total of 120 members. Of these, 72 members are elected to represent single-member electorates throughout the country, while the remaining 48 members are elected from party lists according to the share of the party vote they receive in a general election.

Prime Minister and Governor General Appoint Supreme Court

The Supreme Court of New Zealand is the highest court in the country and is responsible for hearing appeals from lower courts and making final decisions on important legal issues.

The process for appointing Supreme Court judges in New Zealand is as follows:

  1. Nomination: The Attorney-General invites nominations for a vacancy on the Supreme Court from the Chief Justice, the Attorney-General, the Solicitor-General, the President of the Court of Appeal, and the Chief Judge of the High Court. Other judges and the Law Society may also make nominations.
  2. Selection: The Attorney-General consults with the Chief Justice, the Solicitor-General, and the President of the Court of Appeal to create a shortlist of candidates. The shortlisted candidates are then interviewed by the Attorney-General, who makes a recommendation to the Prime Minister.
  3. Appointment: The Prime Minister recommends the appointment of a judge to the Governor-General, who then makes the appointment.

Supreme Court judges are appointed for life, subject to a mandatory retirement age of 70. The appointments process is designed to ensure that only the most qualified and experienced candidates are appointed to the bench.

No Contained Constitution in One Single Document

New Zealand has a written constitution, although it is not contained in a single document like many other countries. Instead, New Zealand’s constitution is made up of a combination of statutes (laws passed by the New Zealand Parliament), common law (legal precedents established by the courts), and constitutional conventions (unwritten rules and practices that govern the operation of government).

One of the most important constitutional documents in New Zealand is the Constitution Act 1986, which sets out the framework for the country’s government and defines the powers and functions of its institutions. Other key constitutional statutes include the Bill of Rights Act 1990 and the Electoral Act 1993.

In addition to these written laws, New Zealand’s constitution is also shaped by various conventions, such as the principle of responsible government (which requires the government to have the support of a majority of members of Parliament) and the principle of the separation of powers (which separates the functions of the executive, legislative, and judicial branches of government).

Overall, while New Zealand’s constitution may not be contained in a single document, it nonetheless provides the framework for the country’s governance and protects the rights and freedoms of its citizens.

In essence, New Zealand’s political system refutes criticism of the judicial reform, which is broadly more similar to New Zealand than Turkey or Hungary, for example, with which the left would like to compare the Netanyahu government’s reform efforts.

Research with help of ChatGPT